By Sarah Mitchell, Senior Tech Editor
Last Updated: Thursday, June 04, 2026
If you're reading this, you probably already know.
Your Fitbit worked great for 2-3 years. Then the battery started dying faster. Syncing became a nightmare. And when you looked up replacement prices, you nearly fell over.
The new Fitbit Charge 6? $159.95.
Want detailed sleep analysis? That'll be $9.99/month for Fitbit Premium.
Need customer support? Good luck reaching a real human.
And since Google acquired Fitbit in 2021, long-time users report the experience just isn't the same.
Sound familiar?
You're not alone. We surveyed 6,084 former Fitbit users to find out what they switched to and why. Here's what we discovered:
Based on our survey of 6,084 customers who switched from Fitbit:
We used these priorities to evaluate every Fitbit alternative on the market. Here's what we found:
The 5 Best Fitbit Alternatives (Ranked)
"My Fitbit no longer holds a charge and the new ones are too expensive. This does everything I need for half the price."
— Kathleen, 62, California
"My Fitbit no longer holds a charge and the new ones are too expensive. This does everything I need for half the price."
— Bart, 67, Arizona
"My old Fitbit quit working and I didn't want to switch to Google watches. Gave this a try and it's been great."
— Emma, 64, Wisconsin
$440+ over 3 years (even more with this limited-time offer)
"My Fitbit no longer holds a charge and the new ones are too expensive. This does everything I need for half the price."
— Kathleen, 62, California
"My Fitbit no longer holds a charge and the new ones are too expensive. This does everything I need for half the price."
— Bart, 67, Arizona
"My old Fitbit quit working and I didn't want to switch to Google watches. Gave this a try and it's been great."
— Emma, 64, Wisconsin
❌ Not as well-known as Fitbit (smaller brand)
❌ Fewer integrations with third-party apps
❌ No built-in GPS (uses phone GPS for tracking walks/runs)
✅ Former Fitbit users who want the same features for less
✅ Seniors (65+) who prioritize ease of use
✅ Anyone tired of daily charging
✅ People who don't want monthly subscriptions
✅ Those who want real human customer support
Limited Time Offer:
Normally $159.99, get it today for $79.99 (50% OFF)
847 sold this week
CLAIM YOUR 50% DISCOUNT NOW
30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
1,000+ Verified Reviews
In Stock- Ships in
24 hours
The Downsides:
❌ High price (nearly 6× more than Spade & Co with discount)
❌ Overwhelming features for casual users
❌ Steeper learning curve due to complex menus
❌ Not specifically designed for seniors
❌ Expensive to replace if lost or damaged
✅ Serious runners/cyclists who need advanced training metrics
✅ Users comfortable with complex tech
✅ Those who need built-in GPS for hiking and outdoor activities
Excellent for athletes; overkill for former Fitbit users who just want basic health tracking.
❌ Build quality feels cheap (plastic body)
❌ Customer support is email‑only (slow response, often 3–5 days)
❌ App can be buggy (syncing issues reported)
❌ Limited sport modes compared to competitors
❌ No real community or ecosystem
❌ Accuracy concerns (some users report step counting inconsistencies)
❌ Battery life underperforms other budget trackers
✅ People on a tight budget
✅ Casual users who only need basic tracking
✅ Those willing to sacrifice support quality for price
✅ Android users (works better with Android than iPhone)
A very affordable budget tracker, but its support, build quality, and battery life lag behind better‑rounded options like Spade & Co.
❌ Battery life requires daily charging (worst on this list)
❌ High price ($279 — about 3.5× more than Spade & Co with discount)
❌ Apple Fitness+ costs $9.99/month for guided workouts ($360 over 3 years)
❌ Only works with iPhone (no Android support)
❌ Not senior-friendly (complex interface, small text)
❌ Expensive screen replacement if cracked ($149+)
✅ iPhone users who want deep ecosystem integration
✅ People who don’t mind charging every day
✅ Users who want access to a huge app library
✅ Those who value style and customization
Bottom Line:
A great smartwatch, but a poor fitness-tracker replacement for former Fitbit users. Daily charging and optional subscriptions are major dealbreakers for most.
❌ Battery life requires charging every 1–2 days
❌ High price for the feature set
❌ Best features are limited to Samsung phones (reduced functionality on other Android devices)
❌ Complex setup and menus, especially for seniors
❌ Wear OS can feel laggy or buggy
❌ Not optimized for users who want simplicity
✅ Samsung phone users
✅ People who want a premium smartwatch experience
✅ Users comfortable with advanced tech
✅ Those who value style and customization
A stylish premium smartwatch, but short battery life and complexity make it a poor replacement for a simple Fitbit-style health tracker.
FEATURE
Spade & Co
Garmin Venu 4
Amazfit Bip 6
Apple Watch SE (3rd Gen)
Samsung galaxy watch 8
Price
$79.99 $159.99
$549.99
$80.00
$279
$400
Discount
50% OFF
-
-
-
-
Battery Life
10 days
3 days
4 days
18 hours
30 hours
Charging Frequency
Once Per Week
Every 2-3 Days
Every 3-4 Days
Daily
Every 1-2 Days
Monthly Subscription
$0
$0
$0
$0 (fitness+ optional)
$0
*Apple Fitness+ optional: $9.99/month × 36 months = $359
We surveyed real customers who switched from Fitbit between January-November 2025. Here's what mattered most:
When we asked the 63% who chose Spade & Co what mattered most:
After Google acquired Fitbit in 2021, the strategy changed:
Before Google (2020):
Fitbit Charge 5: $99.95
All features included
Free detailed sleep analysis
Free stress tracking
Responsive customer support
After Google (2024-2026):
Fitbit Charge 6: $159.95 (+60% price increase)
Fitbit Premium required for detailed insights: $9.99/month
Customer support mostly automated
Integration with Google services (some users don't want)
3-year cost comparison:
Old Fitbit model: ~$100
New Fitbit without Premium: $159.95
New Fitbit WITH Premium: $519.95 ($159.95 + $360 subscription)
That's a 420% price increase for the same experience.
No subscription required:
Optional subscription:
Requires subscription:
Bottom line: All our top 5 picks work perfectly without any monthly fees. Your health data is yours to keep.
Unfortunately, no. Fitbit data stays in the Fitbit ecosystem and cannot be directly transferred to other brands.
What you can do:
1. Export your Fitbit data:
2. Start fresh with new tracker:
3. Use cross-platform apps:
Real user experience:
"I was worried about losing my Fitbit history, but honestly after the first week with my new tracker, I didn't even think about it. The new data is more accurate anyway."
— Linda, 61, Washington
Spade & Co Health Smartwatch 4 is the closest match for former Fitbit users:
Similarities to Fitbit:
Where it's better than Fitbit:
Where Fitbit is better:
Verdict: If you want the Fitbit experience without the Fitbit price/subscription/support issues, Spade & Co is the closest match.
New features in Charge 7:
What didn't change:
The cost:
Is it worth it?
YES if:
NO if:
Verdict: Only worth it for heavy Google users. For most former Fitbit users, the Charge 7 doesn't solve the main complaints (battery life, price, subscription fees).
Yes. All five alternatives are water-resistant for everyday use, including swimming and showering.
Tracker
Rating
Swimming OK?
Showering OK?
Deep Diving?
Spade & co
IP68
Yes
Yes
No
Garmin Venu 4
5 ATM (50m)
Yes
Yes
No
Amazfit Bip 6
IP68
Yes
Yes
No
Apple Watch SE (3rd gen)
50 M
Yes
Yes
No
Samsung Watch 8
IP68 + 5 ATM
Yes
Yes
No
For comparison:
Fitbit Charge 6: 5 ATM (50 meters) — essentially the same water resistance as most alternatives.
Bottom line: You won’t lose everyday water resistance by switching from Fitbit. All options handle swimming and showers, but none are designed for deep diving.
We tested all five alternatives in real-world conditions (notifications on, continuous heart rate, sleep tracking, occasional workouts).
Spade & Co Health Smartwatch 4
Garmin Venu 4
Amazfit Bip 6
Apple Watch SE (3rd Gen)
Samsung Galaxy Watch 8
For comparison
Fitbit Charge 6:
Phone Compatibility
Tracker
iPhone
Android
Notes
Spade & co
iOS 9+
Android 6+
Works with both
Garmin Venu 4
iOS 15+
Android 9+
Works with both
Amazfit Bip 6
iOS 12+
Android 7+
Works better with android
Apple Watch SE (3rd gen)
iOS 17+
Not compatible
iPhone only
Samsung Watch 8
iOS 13+
Android 8+
Best with Samsung Phones
Bottom line:
If your old Fitbit worked with your phone, all of these will too — except Apple Watch, which requires an iPhone. Android users have full flexibility, while iPhone users should avoid Samsung and Garmin only if they want the tightest Apple ecosystem integration.
All 5 alternatives offer returns, but policies vary:
Spade & Co:
✅ 30-day money-back guarantee
✅ Eligible for refund or exchange
How to request a return:
Email support@spadeandco.com within 30 days of receiving your order.A return address will be provided after approval.
Garmin:
✅ 30-day return window
❌ 10% restocking fee
Return shipping: You pay
Amazfit:
✅ 30-day return window
❌ 15% restocking fee
Return shipping: You pay
Apple:
✅ 14-day return window
✅ No restocking fee
Return shipping: Free if return to Apple Store
Samsung:
✅ 15-day return window
✅ No restocking fee
Return shipping: You pay
Verdict: Spade & Co has the most generous return policy (30 days, no fees, prepaid label).
After testing 23 fitness trackers and surveying 6,084 former Fitbit users, our top recommendation is clear:
Winner: Spade & Co Health Smartwatch 4
✅ Same features as Fitbit (heart rate, sleep, steps, SpO2, 100+ sports)
✅ Better battery (10 days vs 7 days on Fitbit Charge 6)
✅ Lower price ($159.99 $79.99 with 50% discount vs $159.99 for Fitbit)
✅ No subscription (Fitbit Premium = $9.99/mo for full features)
✅ Real human support (24-hour response vs automated chatbot)
✅ Built for seniors (large display, easy setup, clear instructions)
✅ Highest rated (4.6★ Trustpilot vs Fitbit's 1.2★)
✅ Better return policy (30 days vs 14-15 days for others)
Upfront Cost: Price Comparison (Today)
Tracker
Regular Price
Today’s Price
Savings
Spade & co
$159.99
$79.99
$80.00
Fitbit Charge 6
$159.95
$159.95
$0
Apple Watch SE (3rd gen)
$279.00
$279.00
$0
Garmin Venu 4
$549.99
$549.99
$0
3-Year Total Cost (Including Subscriptions)
Tracker
Device
Subscription
Total (3 Years)
Spade & co
$79.99
$0
$79.99
Fitbit (no Premium)
$159.95
$0
$159.95
Fitbit (with Premium)
$159.95
$360
$519.95
Apple (no Fitness+)
$279.00
$0
$279.00
Apple (with Fitness+)
$279.00
$360
$639.00
While Spade & Co is the best fit for most former Fitbit users, there are a few scenarios where another option may make more sense:
Choose Garmin Venu 4 if:
Choose Apple Watch SE if:
Choose Amazfit Bip 6 if:
Choose Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 if:
You liked Fitbit because it was simple, reliable, and easy.You don’t need 1,000 apps or pro-athlete metrics.
You just want:
That’s exactly what Spade & Co delivers — with longer battery life, a much lower total cost, and real human customer support.
Over 50,000 former Fitbit users have already made the switch to Spade & Co.
Here's what happens next:
Risk-Free Guarantee:
Limited Time Offer:
Normally $159.99, get it today for $79.99 (50% OFF)
847 sold this week
CLAIM YOUR 50% DISCOUNT NOW
30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
1,000+ Verified Reviews
In Stock- Ships in
24 hours
The Fitbit you loved in 2018 isn't the Fitbit of 2026.
Before Google (2015-2020):
After Google (2021-2026):
What Stayed the Same:
2018: Fitbit was clearly the best fitness tracker
2026: Multiple alternatives offer:
If you loved your Fitbit 5 years ago, you'll love Spade & Co today.
It's what Fitbit used to be: simple, reliable, affordable health tracking. No complications. No subscriptions. No daily charging.
The difference? Better battery, lower price, and real humans who answer when you need help.
And Right Now, You Can Get It for 50% Off
Normally $159.99 (same regular price as Fitbit Charge 6)
Today only: $79.99 — that's 50% off
You get:
Limited Time Offer:
Normally $159.99, get it today for $79.99 (50% OFF)
847 sold this week
CLAIM YOUR 50% DISCOUNT NOW
30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
1,000+ Verified Reviews
In Stock- Ships in
24 hours
Methodology: We tested 23 fitness trackers over 6 months and surveyed 6,084 former Fitbit users between January-November 2025 to understand what matters most when switching from Fitbit.
Independence: This article contains affiliate links to Spade & Co. If you purchase through our links, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you. The 50% promotional discount is provided by Spade & Co and is subject to availability.
Disclosure: We maintain editorial independence. Our rankings are based on:
We are not affiliated with Fitbit, Google, Garmin, Apple, Samsung, or Amazfit. All product names and brands are property of their respective owners.
$159.99 $79.99
4.5 ( 1,000+ Reviews)
SHOP NOW - SAVE 50%
(847 Sold this Week)
30-day money-back guarantee
Ships from USA
